Orca Network News Release - July 23, 2003

News Release

Orca Network

For Immediate Release - July 23, 2003

Contact: Howard Garrett or Susan Berta (360) 678-3451; (360) 661-3739 (cell); or info@orcanetwork.org

Seismological research project that would likely have injured or killed marine mammals, fish, birds and turtles has been POSTPONED!

According to George Spence, the lead scientist for this project at UVIC, the CASSIS project is now postponed for this summer. They are hoping to carry it out next summer but need to present more information regarding the project to the government and public prior to it going ahead.

DFO recommended to Natural Resources Canada (NRCAN) that the CASSIS project be postponed to protect marine mammals. As of this morning Ralph Currie, head of the Pacific Geoscience Centre, assigned to draw up the Environmental Assessment, said "There has been significant concern raised by members of the public and NGOs (non-governmental organizations)." The project was being rescheduled to allow time for more thorough examination of potential effects. The most likely reschedule will be to next year. We expect official word soon. The decision whether or not to continue with the research proposal will likely be made by September.

Nevertheless, it is still a good idea for scientists and the public to keep a close eye on this project and to request participation in the process for next year.

The whales, fish, birds and turtles are safe from the this project for at least another year. We have a variety of scientists and many concerned citizens on both sides of the border to thank for their prompt action, as well as several TV, radio and newspaper media who saw the danger in this project and allowed these serious questions to be broadcast.

For more information, see AquaNews.

News Release

Orca Network

For Immediate Release - July 8, 2003

Contact: Howard Garrett or Susan Berta (360) 678-3451; (360) 661-3739 (cell); or info@orcanetwork.org

Seismological research project will likely injure or kill marine mammals, fish, birds and turtles
See below for information on who to contact to request that this potentially deadly experiment be postponed until it is assured that marine life will be fully and appropriately considered.

A massive international (US/Canada/Japan) seismological research project is planned for late August and early September, 2003, off the south coast of Vancouver Island. This project will use an extremely large air cannon, firing at a volume of 243dB. We understand that this level is higher than the seismic tests in Baja that killed beaked whales (see below). Apparently very few people or agencies knew about this project until the past week. By all appearances, this project was greased along the review process with incomplete data and now is being hurried up to meet a very tight and fast-looming time frame. Severe trauma to marine mammals will almost certainly result from this project if it is allowed to continue as planned, including the Southern Resident Community of orcas which is listed as Depleted under the MMPA in the US and as Endangered under the SARA in Canada.

The CASSIS project
The intro says:
"On the Cascadia convergent margin, massive earthquakes of magnitude 9 or greater occur every 200-600 years, while damaging earthquakes near magnitude 7 occur approximately every 30 years. We propose a major seismological study, the CAScadia collaborative SeISmic experiment (CASSIS), to determine the structural and geodynamical controls on these major earthquakes in southwest British Columbia. We have a short window of opportunity to collaborate with Japanese seismologists, who are willing to allocate significant resources with a value of more than $2M, to a study of Cascadia. The Japanese propose to bring to Canada a modern seismic vessel and about 60 ocean bottom seismometers. We propose to support an active-source marine program with our own research vessel and personnel, and to extend the offshore survery across Vancouver Island and partly the Mainland by deploying at least 100 land seismometers to record the offshore airgun shots and about 10 large dynamite shots in drill holes on land. Complementary passive recording of small local earthquakes will be accomplished using broadband ocean-bottom and land seismometers during a three-month deployment. Earthquakes will also be recorded by the new Canadian semi-portable seismograph network POLARIS and permanent networks run by the Geological Survey of Canada and the University of Washington."
The planned explosions could seriously harm marine mammals that inhabit the south end of Vancouver Island. NOAA Fisheries started getting information about this project only about two or three weeks ago. Canadian DFO had received a permit application, apparently containing inaccurate information, and issued a permit on May 30, giving some guidance to the Canadian researchers in charge of the project including some information on safety buffer zones. DFO has since realized their error with respect to issuing the CASSIS permit, and they have now rescinded the earlier 'recomended mitigations' that they had submitted. Presumably they are now working on a much larger and more stringent set of mitigations.

A number of researchers on the US side are coming forward with information on marine mammal distribution and densities during the proposed work window and on further mitigations. At this time, it appears that the only link the US has to the project is via data collection through shore-based passive listening seismometers. The matter is being discussed at the highest levels in Washington.

The public needs to be informed that the Japanese research vessel Kairei is scheduled to arrive in Victoria on August 7 and that the work is slated to begin approximately August 27 - a time when whales (orcas, humpbacks and several other species) are known to be in the area. That leaves very little time to offer input or organize proper mitigations.

Time is of the essence.

Below is what occurred in Baja California last October:

Judge Halts Baja Research After Two Whale Deaths
SAN FRANCISCO, California, October 29, 2002 (ENS) - A federal district court judge ordered the National Science Foundation to stop using high decibel airguns in the Gulf of California yesterday, citing concern over possible harm to whales that environmentalists believe the research project has caused.
The National Science Foundation (NSF) had been using the airguns to fire high energy acoustic bursts at the sea floor to help map a fault in the earth's crust.
It is these high energy acoustic bursts that The Center for Biological Diversity believes is the likely cause of the death of two beaked whales, which found stranded on September 25 at Isla San Jose in the Gulf of California which separates Mexico's Baja Peninsula from mainland Mexico."

Please help us get the word out about the CASSIS Project to the public and to decision makers on both sides of the border, to prevent this unnecessary threat to our marine mammals.


Susan Berta and Howard Garrett
Orca Network
2403 S. North Bluff Rd
Greenbank,WA 98253
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
www.orcanetwork.org
info@orcanetwork.org

(360) 678-3451
1-866-ORCANET


=======

Below is an extensive list of Canadian contacts that are involved in the CASSIS Seismological Project.

Please feel free to contact any or all of those listed below with your comments and concerns regarding the effects this project will have on marine mammals in the north Pacific. Also included below are some talking points to include in your correspondence. We will update our website with any new information we receive about the project.

Susan Berta & Howard Garrett,
Orca Network

Talking points:
  • The project is scheduled for a time when many species of whales and other marine mammals are present in the project area. John Calambokidis of Cascadia Research has a soon to be published paper with surveys of whales' presence off west Vancouver Island in August, which includes all four populations of orca (Southern Residents, Northern Residents, Transients and Offshores), Humpback Whales, Gray Whales, and appearances of Fin, Sperm, Blue and possibly Right Whales. In fact, Cascadia Research has a marine mammal aerial survey scheduled for August, and such surveys are scheduled at times when a maximum number of whales are present.
  • This project has proceeded in virtual secrecy - many agencies and researchers just found out about it, yet it is scheduled to take place in August/Sept. Previous projects have made efforts to contact researchers in ample time (a year or so in advance) to work out a schedule that would have the least impact on whales and marine mammals, and to give time for proper environmental assessment and mitigation, as well as to schedule observers to be onboard project vessels to look for whales.
  • This type of seismological activity has caused the death of several Beaked Whales off Baja, and though previously not known to harm whales, researchers now believe there is real harm caused by these experiments, and it is certain that sounds of this magnitude that reach over such long distances will kill or injure whales and other marine life.
    (go to http://ens-news.com/ens/oct2002/2002-10-29-10.asp for story on Baja project)
  • Another possible effect of this type of experiment is disturbance of ocean sediments, which would unleash toxins into the water column.
  • At the very least, this experiment MUST BE POSTPONED and not conducted at the scheduled time. The presence of so many species of endangered whales in the area is a fact that cannot be mitigated. The sounds travel too long a distance to be able to ensure no whales are in the area.
  • The best solution would be to CANCEL THE PROJECT. Is the information gained worth the loss of endangered whales? One of the professors involved has admitted that this research will not help predict earthquakes, but will only help determine how big future quakes might be. This information is being gathered by other researchers and projects that have less of an impact on ocean life.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
CASSIS PROJECT CONTACTS:

Principal Investigators:
George D. Spence, UVic, gspence@uvic.ca, ph:+1-250-721-6187
Roy D. Hyndman, GSC/PGC, rhyndman@nrcan.gc.ca, ph:+1-250-363-642
Andy J. Calvert, SFU, acalvert@sfu.ca, ph:+1-604-291-5511

Researchers:
Michael Bostock, UBC, bostock@eos.ubc.ca, ph:+1-604-822-2082
John Cassidy, PGC, cassidy@pgc.nrcan.gc.ca, ph:+1-250-363-6500
Earl Davis, PGC, davis@pgc.nrcan.gc.ca, ph:+1-250-363-6453
Stan Dosso, UVic, sdosso@uvic.ca, ph:+1-250-472-5245
Nathan Hayward, SFU, nhayward@sfu.ca
Keith Louden, Dalhousie, Keith.Louden@Dal.Ca, ph:+1-902-494-3452
Garry Rogers, PGC, rogers@pgc.nrcan.gc.ca, ph:+1-250-363-6500
Martin Scherwath, UVic, mscherwa@uvic.ca, ph:+1-250-721-6196
Kelin Wang, PGC, wang@pgc.nrcan.gc.ca, ph:+1-250-363-6429

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Canadian Agencies Conducting Environmental Reviews of the CASSIS Project:

ENVIRONMENT CANADA:
Matteau Yanick is overseeing the CASSIS Project and environmental review for Environment Canada:
Matteau Yanick
Environmental Assessment Officer,
CSS/RPESB/OEA
Natural Resources Canada
580 Booth Street, 3rd Floor, Room. A7
Ottawa, ON
Canada K1A 0E4
Telephone: (613) 992-8791
Fax : (613) 995-5719
ymatteau@nrcan.gc.ca

David Anderson
Minister's Office (Minister's Regional Office)
Environment Canada
Minister's Regional Office
300 West Georgia Street, Suite 808
Vancouver, British Columbia
Canada V6B6B4
Telephone:(604) 666-4500
Fax:(604) 666-4524
david.anderson@ec.gc.ca

Environmental Office of Natural Resources Canada
Minister Herb Dhaliwal
hdhaliwa@nrcan.gc.ca
(613) 996-2007

George Anderson, Deputy Minister
ganderso@nrcan.gc.ca
(613) 992-3456

Alexandra Muir
Director of Communications
Office of the Minister
Natural Resources Canada
Ottawa
(613) 947-8246 Ghyslain Charron
Media Relations
Natural Resources Canada
Ottawa
(613) 992-4447

Dr. Ralph Currie has been assigned the draw up the Environmental Assessment:
Dr. Ralph G. Currie
Pacific Geoscience Centre
Geological Survey of Canada
P. O. Box 6000
9860 West Saanich Rd
Sidney, BC V8L 4B2
currie@pgc.nrcan.gc.ca
Phone: (250) 363-6419
Fax: (250) 363-6739

Department of Fisheries and oceans (DFO)
Honourable Robert Thibault
House of Commons
Minister of Fisheries and Oceans Canada
Parliament Buildings, Wellington Street
Ottawa, ON K1A 0A6
Canada
Tel: (613) 996-2358
Fax: (613) 952-1458
E-Mail: Min@dfo-mpo.gc.ca

Central Contact:
Fisheries and Oceans Canada
Policy & Communications Branch
200 - 401 Burrard Street
Vancouver, BC, V6C 3S4
Canada
Tel : 604-666-0384
Fax: 604-666-1847
info@dfo-mpo.gc.ca

Marilyn Joyce
Marine Mammal Resource Coordinator
Fisheries and Oceans Canada - Pacific Region
200 - 401 Burrard Street
Vancouver, BC V6B 5G3
Telephone: (604) 666-9965
Facsimile: (604) 666-3341
Cellular: (604) 813-5314
JoyceM@pac.dfo-mpo.gc.ca

Canadian Agencies receiving CASSIS Project Description for Comment and Input:
Parks Canada Environment Canada
Geneviève Patenaude
External Relations Branch
Parks Canada
25 Eddy Street
Gatineau, Quebec
K1A 0M5
Tel: (819) 997-7786
Fax: (819) 997-5974
information@pc.gc.ca

Transport Canada
National headquarters
The Honourable David M. Collenette, P.C., M.P., Minister of Transport.
Tower C, Place de Ville, 330 Sparks Street
Ottawa, Ontario
K1A 0N5

Transport Canada
Pacific Region (British Columbia)
620 - 800 Burrard Street
Vancouver, British Columbia
V6Z 2J8
Telephone: (604) 666-3518
Fax: (604) 666-7255

Indian and Northern Affairs
Minister
Robert D. Nault
Indian and Northern Affairs Canada
Terrasses de la Chaudière
10 Wellington, North Tower
Hull, Quebec
Postal Address:
Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0H4
Fax No. (819) 953-4941
NAPInfo@ainc-inac.gc.ca

Health Canada
Minister's Office - Health Canada
Anne McLellan, Minister
Brooke Claxton Bldg., Tunney's Pasture
P.L. 0906C
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
K1A 0K9
Fax: 613-952-1154
Minister_Ministre@hc-sc.gc.ca

Industry Canada
Allan Rock, Minister
11th Floor, East Tower
C.D. Howe Building
235 Queen Street
Ottawa ON K1A 0H5
Canada
Tel.: (613) 995-9001
Fax: (613) 992-0302
E-mail: Minister.Industry@ic.gc.ca

Industry Canada
Pacific Region (British Columbia and Yukon)
Suite 2000
300 West Georgia Street
Vancouver, British Columbia
V6B 6E1
Tel.: (604) 666-5000
Fax: (604) 666-8330

Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council
Tom Brzustowski
President
350 Albert Street
Ottawa, Ontario
K1A 1H5
tom.brzustowski@nserc.ca
(613) 995-5840

The Nuu Chah nulth Tribal Council was consulted regarding the onland portion of the project (as were five other but un-named First Nations):

Nuu chah nulth Tribal Council
PO Box 1383
Port Alberni, BC
V9Y 7M2
(250) 724-5757
(250) 723-0463 Fax
amasso@nuuchahnulth.org (NTC Office Manager, Southern Region)
patriciam@nuuchahnulth.org (NTC Office Manager, Northern Region)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


Back to Orca Network News Releases


Home

Search

Top

©Orca Network
Please contact
Orca Network to inquire
about educational use of any materials on this site.